View Poll Results: A superb series finale or a disappointing conclusion?
- Voters
- 45. You may not vote on this poll
-
10/10 - SQUEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!
4 8.89% -
9/10 - That was awesome, and nearly perfect.
9 20.00% -
8/10 - Enjoyable stuff! RTD can have my babies.
3 6.67% -
7/10 - Woo!Can't wait for Christmas!
6 13.33% -
6/10 - It was alright, but could've been better.
2 4.44% -
5/10 - I'm sitting on the fence.
4 8.89% -
4/10 - RTD's let me down once again.
6 13.33% -
3/10 - I can smell OG burning.
2 4.44% -
2/10 - Second To Last Of The Time Lords
2 4.44% -
1/10 - Last Of The Time Lords.
7 15.56%
Results 151 to 175 of 207
-
2nd Jul 2007, 3:53 PM #151One of the things I disliked most about the episode was the 'turning back of time' to make everything okay. When I saw the 'one year later' bit at the start I thought 'Great, some lasting consequences!'.
Si xx
I've just got my handcuffs and my truncheon and that's enough.
-
2nd Jul 2007, 4:02 PM #152
No, because a space program would have to be unbelievably advanced to have encountered aliens from beyond the solar system. Britain went to Mars. In space terms that's the equivalent of popping next door to borrow a cup of sugar (did anyone actually ever do that? how did it become a cliche?!). Time experiments are local, on the Earth, and so are dinosaurs. Sarah Jane is investigating time research in that very story!
For goodness sake Jason, what's the point in inventing a different excuse for each old series invasion, just to try and concince us that they are somehow more convincing of anything in the new series?
[Edited to add
Looking back over the show, I can only find four stories in the whole series that showed a roughly contemporary invasion attempt that is explicity worldwide in scope. The Tenth Plnet, for most witnesses, probably left them somewhat bemused: Mondas appears, Cybermen arrive, and then they all keel over and die! The Invasion happened while the entire population ws unconscious. Spearhead From Space saw window dummies coming to life. Only a few people know that it's an alien controlling them. The Claws Of Axos involves worlwide distribution of axonite and then it all disappears, while only a handful of people actually saw Axos itself. Every other invasion was highly localised, and few people actually saw the aliens. OK, looking back the Skarasen was seen by loads, but it's the Loch Ness Monster? Who actually saw the Zygons? UNIT and co, and that's about it.Last edited by Jason Thompson; 2nd Jul 2007 at 4:29 PM.
-
2nd Jul 2007, 4:57 PM #153
Oh that kid was a Blue Peter competition winner was he/she? Explains a lot.
Another thing I didn't like... Martha's mum being kept prisoner and humiliated for a year by a man she watched try to kill her daugher, a man who she watched slaughter vast swathes of humanity and lay waste to the Earth, a man she swore to kill when she got a chance. Then she gets a perfect chance... but can't go through with it because she's a "good" person. B****cks. Anyone other than a total pacifist saint-like character would have shot him in the face and kicked his lifeless body until she broke some bones in her foot. I really do hate it when people write these situations and always show good people as being incapable of pulling the trigger, even under extreeeeeeme stress, as if that would somehow invalidate their goodness. It's a very black and white and not particularly believable view of human nature in my opinion.
-
2nd Jul 2007, 5:09 PM #154Pip Madeley Guest
It's a bloody kid's show!
What do you want, a gore-fest where Francine shoots the Master in the head? That's a good example for the children watching.
-
2nd Jul 2007, 5:13 PM #155
I don't know about how they affected you, but to me the terrorist attacks were just something I saw on the news. Nasty as they were they only killed about 50 people and happened (as I always suspected such things probably would) in a large capital city in which I don't live. I didn't know anyone who died in them, or know anyone who knew someone who was died or injured. I know that I'm much more likely to die being killed in a traffic accident or having a freak accident with a sponge around the home than I am to even be in the same AREA as a terrorist attack going off. It wasn't really world-changing at all. Now hordes of alien death machines patrolling the streets of every town and city in every country all over the world and butchering indiscriminately... that would probably have more of an impact on most people.
-
2nd Jul 2007, 5:14 PM #156
This Doctor sure loves giving people second chances though doesn't he?
-
2nd Jul 2007, 5:17 PM #157
-
2nd Jul 2007, 5:20 PM #158
-
2nd Jul 2007, 5:22 PM #159
-
2nd Jul 2007, 5:25 PM #160
Or sarcarstic
-
2nd Jul 2007, 5:26 PM #161mostly localised (on a global scale)
Every other invasion was highly localised, and few people actually saw the aliens. OK, looking back the Skarasen was seen by loads, but it's the Loch Ness Monster? Who actually saw the Zygons? UNIT and co, and that's about it.
Si.
-
2nd Jul 2007, 5:26 PM #162WhiteCrow Guest
Here's something which might cause some fuss. Surely for a typical Master story, the alien menace he'd allied with should have turned on even him?
Or will some people say once again it's RTD breaking all the rules ...
-
2nd Jul 2007, 6:36 PM #163Or possibly just cut the scene out then? It didn't add anything other than to show how "good" Martha's mum is, which we didn't really need to be told anyway, and to do it in a rather cliched and crap way.
Si xx
I've just got my handcuffs and my truncheon and that's enough.
-
2nd Jul 2007, 7:02 PM #164
Interesting...
I'm glad I'm not alone in loving the 'super old' Doctor. I thought it was a marvellous effect, and just heartbreaking to see our hero at his lowest ever ebb. Is it just because I'm not a "Lord of the Rings" fan that I enjoyed this aspect of the show? People seem to hate it just because he looks like Gollum or whatever it is.
Also, no-one has commented on the one truly striking moment in the story - when the Master kicks the Doctor in the face! I found that really disturbing, perhaps even a step too far. At that moment the Master went from being a villain I loved to hate to one I just hated, which wasn't a nice feeling. But a very powerful moment.
It's always nice to have a diversity of opinions, but personally I don't care about the credibility or otherwise of a world where alien invasions are becoming the norm - I just really thoroughly enjoyed it, and was genuinely relieved when Tennant DIDN'T regenerate at the end.
-
2nd Jul 2007, 7:35 PM #165
I do get where Jason is coming from, because the old series retained an element of mystery (for want of a btter word). the events depicte din the series are undoubtedly ficticious and fantastical, but there's the idea that they might actually be happening out there somewhere. You'd never know. I like that.
I don't really want huge spaceships crashing into Big Ben; much prefer something more subtle and insidious going on.
A global invasion that the billions know about is very different to most old Who scenarios. Not saying it's a worse direction, but I was relieved when the 'paradox' was undone, as it stopped the series completely going off into a changed Earth. I think it's important the contemporary Earth in "Doctor Who" is as near to ours as possible; I think that works better.
-
2nd Jul 2007, 8:52 PM #166
I think Jason's argument is quite good, and it is true that most alien invasions in Who are small and are localised. The times when it's more difficult to explain away are spread quite thinly across the series - the Skarasen is a case in point, though that was a single monster that arguably wasn't seen again. People will go on about "Wow, we saw a monster!"... but that arguably doesn't have the same lasting consequences as an army of Cybermen bursting into every house down your road. The Auton invasion is a better parallel, because that was a bunch of monsters storming around and gunning people down. (Though one could argue that most people wouldn't assume them to be aliens/monsters, more like an army of thugs - an Auton gunning somebody down is less "alien" than a flying Dalek shooting a highly visible deathray) The Auton invasion is one of those invasions that would be difficult to cover up, certainly. But then the next story we had the Silurians... but the only people who witness them and are alive by the end of the story are UNIT (who deal with this thing regularly now) and the staff of the base, who will probably be rounded up and made to sign official secrets act stuff - and if they tell their families, who's going to believe them? You've got that plague, but who's going to equate a contagious disease with a race of lizard men in Devesham (or wherever)? Equally, who on Earth is going to think that an attack on London was perpetrated by robot Yeti?
Most of the alien invasions in old Who ran along more secretive lines; highly visible Auton invasions and Skarasen sightings are the exception, not the norm. The New Series has featured a lot of rather-difficult-to-explain-away events, that are either witnessed by entire populations or else ought to have huge consequences that aren't mentioned. I think we ought to be seeing consequences of it, some recognition that humanity's coming to terms with this sort of thing. People always went on about The Faceless Ones: "Why has nobody bar Samantha Briggs noticed that their loved ones are disappearing and never coming back?" It poked a hole in the credibility of the story. Nobody seems to make such accusations against the new series. Perhaps New Who gets by because it's generally entertaining whereas The Faceless Ones was so boring it wasn't worth arguing about, but the criticism stands.
The other problem I have with it is that massive alien invasions that are actually succeeding are too difficult for Doctor Who to defeat. I know it sounds silly. But hear me out. The Doctor can easily blow up an alien spearhead, but when aliens are worldwide what solution can you come up with? So far it's been pull a lever and suck them up through a door in Canary Wharf, or make sure it never happened via a handy paradox machine. The larger the threat the more difficult the solution is going to be, and the solutions generally seem too easy compared to the threat - you need to feel satisfied. There has to be enough sacrifice, enough sweat and tears to equal the threat being posed. When the Doctor resorts to blowing up the aliens it's not that interesting but you arguably don't expect a "Wow, fantastic!" solution to a threat posed by 3 aliens in a small ship; when something truly interesting does happen, it's a bonus. But when the Doctor's up against a billion Daleks we need something a bit more meaty. Rose turning into a god to defeat an entire army of Daleks was rightly criticised; the solution seemed too handy, not difficult enough. It killed the Doctor, certainly, but it still didn't feel right.
Doctor Who works well on a small scale, but whenever it's made larger it opens problems of resolution satisfaction. Even The Invasion falls prey to this; there are no lasting consequences as everybody's unconscious, so credibility is maintained, but it's a bit of a cop-out when an entire invading force is neutralised by blowing up a small hut - followed by 5 minutes of people peering intently at monitors and waiting for the spaceships to blow up. Perhaps that's why the writer hardly even references the Invasion itself and is far more interested in the human shenanigans of Vaughan and lots of people nipping back and forth from the same three buildings. I've never found The Invasion very satisfying because the invading Cybermen do nothing and they're repelled far too swiftly after an 8 episode build up. Again, I say that Doctor Who works well within certain boundaries and when you go beyond them you better have a good story with a cracking resolution to make it work. If you can't think of a better solution to a worldwide invading force (in the process of invading) than to flick a switch or to turn into a demi-god to sort them out, then don't write yourself such a massive problem. Most of us loved Blink for damn good reasons, ingenious plotting and a fun solution being two of them. The Empty Doctor Dances has a bigger problem but deals with it in a good way carefully layered into the plot that feels satisfying.
So that's my problem with all these continuous massive threats in New Who: they stretch credibility when taking the New Series as a whole, and they don't lend themselves well to satisfying resolutions.Last edited by The Secretive Bus; 2nd Jul 2007 at 8:59 PM.
"I remember because cherries send me into a wild fury!"
-
2nd Jul 2007, 9:04 PM #167
But surely in mentioning "The Faceless Ones" you've given at least one example where the old series DID stretch credibility. And you're really just doing what Jason did earlier, listing every old series invasion that was no less noticable than Big Ben being destroyed or Cybermen marching through China, and making up some excuse for it. "People wouldn't think Autons were monsters" etc. etc (because an army of something terrestrial marches through shop windows firing energy bolts from its hands). What's the point? Has there ever been such a long discussion in order to prove something that doesn't really matter?
Time to move on from this?
Si.
-
2nd Jul 2007, 9:19 PM #168Here's something which might cause some fuss. Surely for a typical Master story, the alien menace he'd allied with should have turned on even him?
There's something I like as well. The Master uses the humans from the future as a weapon, twisting their hopes and fears into madness. The Doctor uses the hopes of the present day humans, not as a weapon, but as a defence against the Master. I think that's a lovely inversion that just about defines the two characters.
Even more controversial, the Master's plan MADE SENSE AND NEARLY WORKED!!!! Choke it down, Davison!Pity. I have no understanding of the word. It is not registered in my vocabulary bank. EXTERMINATE!
-
2nd Jul 2007, 9:21 PM #169
Time to probably piss you off now, because I've come into this discussion late! ...but they're right to say that a bunch of Autons is far easier to explain than a global invasionof Cybermen. I'm a bit on the fence on this one I suppose. I think the old series had an understanding about how it would prsent such things. There would be an idea that these things were covered up and kept as secret as possible, and aliens were outside of most people's experience. It's far scarier to present modern day Earth as close to possible as it is, so the alien element is far more effective in my opinion. I don't really want "Independence day" every week! I think the new series likes to present a mdoern day epic scenario were millions are obviously threatened by a very visible menace, which was very rare in the old series. It presumably makes the modern hisotry element in the new series almost an 'alternative Earth', and I'm not sure that's such a great idea. In the old days you'd have UNIT or whoever fighting very small scale invasions, as mentioned, which were easily covered up. Even in "The faceless ones" we're not really in the same style of storytelling as the new series- there always felt like there was a 'get out clause'.
It's an interesting stylistic difference, and one of the few things I've not liked about the new WHo since it came back. From the moment No. 10 blew up I think! Saying that, I did like all the epic season finales.
But less is more strange and mysterious- and I like that.
-
2nd Jul 2007, 9:30 PM #170
-
2nd Jul 2007, 10:58 PM #171
And I stated how the old series did stretch credibility in other cases also. I'm not going to be blind and say the old series was perfect and the most logically and believably plotted TV show ever, because it wasn't. Still, if you don't even care about what I'm saying (which, on the evidence of what you say below, you don't) then I suppose it's silly of me to even bother trying to engage in debate. I even neatly summarised why it's an issue with me in the last paragraph.
Has there ever been such a long discussion in order to prove something that doesn't really matter?
Time to move on from this?
Si.
There are various things I could say to retaliate but there'd really be no point. If you don't care about what I have to say then ignore it, instead of being so bloody rude.
Real smooth, Si."I remember because cherries send me into a wild fury!"
-
2nd Jul 2007, 11:21 PM #172
That's grossly unfair David, and ignores the fact that Jason has been hammering home the exact same points all afternoon, that's what I was referring to, not just your post - I'm just tired of the discussion that's all.
Anyway, whatever. I've had enough too.
Si.
-
2nd Jul 2007, 11:25 PM #173Every invasion was HIGHLY localised... apart from the bloody Loch ness Monster trawling over England!
And the London Underground being evacuated and filled with a web-like fungus!
And London being filled with Dinosaurs!
And London being over-run with living plastic dummies!
Do you think London is so insignificant that it would be invaded by aliens and the rest of the world wouldn't notice!
Yes, the old series stretched credibility, but never to this degree. it's easier to dismiss an event that only affected one city, especially if no-one actually sees anything definitively alien in the event.
That said, it's nice that at least Martha's family remeber those events, so there is still some emotional impact from the Master's activities.
I'd love to see a scene set in a pub, with two blokes recalling the Cybermen invasion of 2007 and comparing it to the invasion of 1986. 'Aye, that were a weird one. These great big weird men arrived, declared they controlled the world, then ten minutes later they all just fell over and shrivelled up. What happened last year? These great big metal men turned up, declared they ran the world, then ten minutes later they all sort of zipped up into the air and disappeared. They're not great at this invading lark, are they?'Last edited by Jason Thompson; 2nd Jul 2007 at 11:32 PM.
-
2nd Jul 2007, 11:35 PM #174
Respectfully, Si, if you are tired of the discussion then just stop replying to it. Don't try to get the last word by rattling off a reply, then declaring you're tired of the conversation so we should forget it.
You'll no doubt be pleased to know that is the last I will be saying on the matter, since I am in Malta for the next week or so and expect this thread to have moved on by the time I get back.
-
2nd Jul 2007, 11:42 PM #175
Rtd Raped My Childhood
Similar Threads
-
Rate and Discuss: Time-Flight
By SiHart in forum ...to Season 19!Replies: 25Last Post: 25th Oct 2014, 11:27 PM -
Rate and Discuss: The Time Warrior
By SiHart in forum ...to Season 11!Replies: 22Last Post: 3rd Jul 2011, 10:17 AM -
Rate and Discuss: Time and the Rani
By SiHart in forum ...to Season 24!Replies: 30Last Post: 5th Dec 2010, 10:49 AM -
Rate and Discuss: The Time of Angels
By SiHart in forum The New SeriesReplies: 89Last Post: 8th Jul 2010, 8:42 AM -
Rate & Discuss 4.17: The End Of Time, Part One
By Pip Madeley in forum The New SeriesReplies: 97Last Post: 4th Jan 2010, 11:35 AM
PSAudios 6.1. Bless You Doctor Who
[/URL] (Click for large version) Doctor Who A thrilling two-part adventure starring Brendan Jones & Paul Monk & Paul Monk Bless You,...
23rd Nov 2020, 3:02 PM