Rate and Discuss: Amy's Choice

[Si Hunt]

Yet John Barrowman has been credited. It's odd! Do the titles discriminate against bumbling young boys?

Si.

[Rob McCow]

Should the guy who played Adam in series 1 have been credited?

I think John Barrowman was credited because he's a BIG star, with his OWN SHOW~! Rather than due to how many lines he had or how important he was to the plot. Rory is a much better character than that woman from Planet of The Dead, but Michelle Collins got into the titles didn't she?*


*I think she did, can't remember for sure.

[SiHart]

John Barrowman wasn't credited until he returned in Series 3 was he?

Si xx

[Logo Polish]

Should the guy who played Adam in series 1 have been credited?

I think John Barrowman was credited because he's a BIG star, with his OWN SHOW~! Rather than due to how many lines he had or how important he was to the plot. Rory is a much better character than that woman from Planet of The Dead, but Michelle Collins got into the titles didn't she?*


*I think she did, can't remember for sure.

I think you must be referring to Michelle Ryan, and yes, she did.

John Barrowman wasn't credited until he returned in Series 3 was he?

Si xx

Indeed not.

[Rob McCow]

Quite right! I'd totally forgotten whats-her-face's name who played Mrs Posh-Thief Von Hoity-Toity from that-one-with-the-bus. Michelle Collins indeed! :embarassed

Who was it for The End Of Time - Bernard Cribbins and John Simm? I guess Timothy Dalton doesn't count. But John Simm wasn't credited in The Sound of Drums.... so the only rule must be that there are no rules.

[Antony Cox]

I really enjoyed this episode!

Proper 'mystery' Doctor Who story which left me guessing right until the end!

[Andrew Curnow]

Surely Si, you mean "the only logic is... that there isn't any logic!"

[Martin Curnow]

I was a bit worried coming into this episode, but have to say I really enjoyed it. I'd been out boozing on a lads day last Saturday and so started to watch it about midnight and fell asleep twice (damn birdsong) and had to go back and start again. I then gave up and watched it on Sunday morning in the end.

A 9/10 from me.

[Jon Masters]

Finally caught up with this one, and glad that it was great - 9/10 - an excellent idea, explored in a great way, and in a story with time to breathe - so that you had time to think about what was gong on, and solve some of the mystery yourself. The Macguffin was of no consequence, because the performances of all 4 main characters was just brilliant. Why didn't they manage to write proper emotional stuff like this for Amy and Rory in the grand finale ? This is hundreds of times more believable.

More like this please - the Dream Lord must return !